At McArthur’s, we believe every couple deserves not only a beautiful wedding cake, but a truly unforgettable one, rich in flavor and remembered long after the last slice is served.
Your journey begins with our Cake Sampling Box (Please click here to order your sample box) thoughtfully curated to help you explore our most-loved flavors. Each box includes:
8 of our most popular cake flavors
6 of our most popular cake fillings
Detailed information on tier cake sizing, pricing, and ordering
Once you’ve enjoyed your samples, simply email weddings@mcarthurs.com to schedule your phone cake consultation with Hollie, our wedding consultant. This consultation allows us to review your selections, discuss sizing, and answer any questions as you plan the perfect cake for your celebration.
Tier Cake Offerings
McArthur’s offers tiered cakes up to 3 tiers.
Tier cake pricing begins at $6.50 per slice.
Base pricing includes:
White, Yellow, Chocolate, or Marble cake flavors
White or Ivory buttercream icing
Buttercream filling
Tier Cake Base Pricing:
2-Tier Cakes
Serves 46 – $299
Serves 58 – $377
Serves 81 – $526.50
3-Tier Cakes
Serves 68 – $442
Serves 102 – $663
Serves 135 – Starting at $877.50
(Additional flavors, fillings, and design elements may be available at an additional cost.)
Ready to Begin?
Order your Cake Sampling Box to get started - Please click here to order your sample box
Email weddings@mcarthurs.com to schedule your phone consultation or for general questions about McArthurs wedding cakes
- Please note: All McArthur’s wedding cakes are for pickup only.
We look forward to being a sweet part of your celebration and helping you create a cake that’s just as memorable as your love story.
Please click here to order your sample box